Maturity Index vs Strength–Maturity Relationship
If the strength–maturity curve fits the test data well, the maturity calculation behind it must be sound.
Does not follow. A poor parameter choice is absorbed into the fit rather than exposed by it. A tight curve is not evidence that the datum temperature or Q value was right.1. Maturity calculation
The temperature history is processed using a selected maturity function. ASTM C1074 permits either the Nurse–Saul temperature–time factor or the Arrhenius-based equivalent age, each with its own parameter — datum temperature or Q respectively.
2. Strength calibration
Concrete specimens are tested for compressive strength at known maturity values. The resulting data are used to establish a strength–maturity relationship for the concrete mixture.
The important qualification
A good strength–maturity curve does not automatically prove that every choice made in calculating the maturity index is optimal. ASTM C1074 states that estimated-strength accuracy depends partly on appropriate maturity-function parameters, and for maximum accuracy provides procedures for determining suitable mixture-specific values. A well-fitting curve produced with a poorly chosen datum temperature is still a well-fitting curve — the error is absorbed into the fit rather than revealed by it.
Choosing the fitted form matters too
The logarithmic form S = a + b·log(M), proposed by Plowman in 1956, remains popular because it plots as a straight line on a log maturity axis. Carino and Lew set out its limitations plainly: it represents the relationship poorly at low and high maturity values, and it implies strength increases indefinitely with maturity, with no limiting strength. They show a case where it fits measured data noticeably less well than a hyperbolic function over a range from about 0.4 to 28 days equivalent age.
This is worth checking in any spreadsheet or dashboard that fits a maturity curve. A log-linear fit chosen for convenience will tend to overestimate at high maturity and misrepresent the earliest readings, which are often the ones a striking decision depends on.
Related pages
References
- Standard ASTM C1074-19e1 — Standard Practice for Estimating Concrete Strength by the Maturity Method.
- Paper Carino, N. J. and Lew, H. S. (2001) — The Maturity Method: From Theory to Application. Proceedings of the 2001 Structures Congress & Exposition, ASCE.
- Paper Plowman, J. M. (1956) — Maturity and the Strength of Concrete. Magazine of Concrete Research, 8(22), 13–22.
- Report ACI 228.1R-19 — Report on Methods for Estimating In-Place Concrete Strength.
Standards are cited by identifier and title. Consult the current licensed standard text before making project decisions. Publisher links were verified on 11 August 2026 and should be rechecked before publication.
Content and sources last reviewed 11 August 2026.