Nurse–Saul vs Arrhenius Maturity Functions
The maturity method is a single defined method; which function is used is an implementation detail.
Incorrect. The function encodes an assumption about how temperature affects the rate of strength gain, and that assumption is mixture-specific. The choice changes the answer.| Approach | Concept | Key parameter | Origin | Important consideration |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nurse–Saul / temperature–time factor | Accumulates temperature above a datum temperature over time; assumes the initial rate of strength gain varies linearly with temperature. | Datum temperature (T₀) | Nurse (1949), Saul (1951) | Accuracy depends on an appropriate datum temperature, and the linear assumption weakens over wide temperature ranges. |
| Arrhenius / equivalent age | Converts actual age to equivalent age at a reference temperature, allowing a non-linear relationship between temperature and rate of strength development. | Q, the apparent activation energy divided by the gas constant | Freiesleben Hansen and Pedersen (1977) | The temperature sensitivity parameter is mixture-dependent. |
Where these came from
Both originate in British research on accelerated and steam curing in the late 1940s and early 1950s, published in the Magazine of Concrete Research. Saul's statement of the maturity rule — that concrete of the same mixture at the same maturity has approximately the same strength, whatever combination of time and temperature produced it — is the assumption the whole method rests on.
The equivalent-age function proposed by Freiesleben Hansen and Pedersen in 1977 addressed the main weakness of the linear approach. C1074 notes that 20 °C has traditionally been used as the specified temperature, and permits any other convenient value such as 23 °C provided it is reported alongside the equivalent age. An equivalent age quoted without its reference temperature is incomplete by the standard's own terms.
Why this matters
ASTM C1074 recognises both the temperature–time factor and equivalent-age expressions of maturity, and states that the accuracy of estimated strength depends on properly determining the maturity function for the particular mixture. Approximate values sit in Appendix X1 — a datum temperature of 0 °C and Q of roughly 5000 K, both stated for Type I cement without admixtures, with the datum figure further limited to a 0–40 °C curing range. Reported activation energies for that cement fall around 40,000–45,000 J/mol.
Where maximum accuracy is required, T₀ or Q are determined experimentally under Annex A1: mortar cubes cured in three water baths, two set at the maximum and minimum in-place temperatures expected and the third midway, with rate constants extracted from the strength–age data. Annex A1 is mandatory information; the appendices holding the approximations are not.
A caution the standard makes about instruments
C1074 carries a note directly relevant to anyone buying a maturity system. Commercial instruments apply specific built-in values of datum temperature or activation energy, so the maturity index they display may not be the true value for the mixture being monitored. For temperature–time instruments the standard supplies a correction where the assumed datum temperature is wrong. For equivalent-age instruments it states that displayed readings cannot be corrected afterwards for the appropriate activation energy — which makes the value an instrument was configured with something to establish before the pour rather than after it.
Which function suits a given mix?
There is no universally correct answer, and that is the substantive finding rather than a hedge. Carino and Lew state it directly: the applicable maturity function is related to the temperature sensitivity of initial strength development, and no single maturity function applies to all concrete mixtures. The function for a given concrete is identified by measuring how the rate constant for strength gain varies with curing temperature.
Their work quantifies the stakes. Where the apparent activation energy is low, around 30 kJ/mol, the age conversion factor is nearly linear in temperature and Nurse–Saul is a reasonable approximation. At around 60 kJ/mol it is strongly non-linear and Nurse–Saul becomes inaccurate — with the error growing as curing temperature departs further from the reference temperature. For concrete at w/c 0.45, measured values ranged from about 30 to 64 kJ/mol depending on cementitious materials and admixtures.
Related pages
References
- Standard ASTM C1074-19e1 — Standard Practice for Estimating Concrete Strength by the Maturity Method.
- Paper Carino, N. J. and Lew, H. S. (2001) — The Maturity Method: From Theory to Application. Proceedings of the 2001 Structures Congress & Exposition, ASCE.
- Paper Nurse, R. W. (1949) — Steam Curing of Concrete. Magazine of Concrete Research, 1(2), 79–88.
- Paper Saul, A. G. A. (1951) — Principles Underlying the Steam Curing of Concrete at Atmospheric Pressure. Magazine of Concrete Research, 2(6), 127–140.
- Paper Freiesleben Hansen, P. and Pedersen, J. (1977) — Maturity Computer for Controlled Curing and Hardening of Concrete. Nordisk Betong, 1, 19–34.
Standards are cited by identifier and title. Consult the current licensed standard text before making project decisions. Publisher links were verified on 11 August 2026 and should be rechecked before publication.
Content and sources last reviewed 11 August 2026.