OTB Technical Reference

Maturity and Low-Carbon Concrete

The claim addressed

Two opposing claims are common: that low-carbon concrete cannot be reliably maturity monitored; and that any mix can be monitored provided the sensor has a calibration curve.

Both are wrong. Low-carbon mixes can be monitored well, but not by inheriting default parameters. The binder system changes the temperature sensitivity the maturity function is meant to represent.
Low-carbon concrete is not automatically unsuitable for maturity monitoring, but binder changes make mix-specific understanding more important.

Why binder chemistry matters

Replacing part of the Portland cement with GGBS, PFA or other supplementary cementitious materials changes hydration kinetics, heat evolution and strength development. The temperature history may therefore differ substantially from a conventional Portland-cement mix, and so may the mixture's sensitivity to that temperature.

The parameter problem, quantified

This is the part that is often skipped. The temperature sensitivity of a mixture is not a constant of concrete — it is a property of the binder system. Carino and Lew measured apparent activation energies ranging from roughly 30 to 64 kJ/mol at w/c 0.45, and roughly 31 to 56 kJ/mol at w/c 0.60, depending on the cementitious materials and admixtures used.

That range spans the region where the choice of maturity function stops being a matter of convenience. At the low end, the linear Nurse–Saul assumption is a fair approximation. At the high end it is not, and the resulting error grows with the difference between the curing temperature and the reference temperature — precisely the condition of a UK winter pour.

ASTM C1074's approximate parameter values in Appendix X1 — datum temperature 0 °C, Q around 5000 K — are stated for Type I cement without admixtures. A substantially blended low-carbon mix, almost certainly with admixtures, sits outside the conditions those approximations were framed for. That is precisely the case in which the standard sends the user to Annex A1 to determine parameters experimentally, and Annex A1 is mandatory information rather than guidance.

The standard also warns that commercial maturity instruments apply built-in datum temperature or activation-energy values, so a displayed index may not be the true value for the mixture in question — and that equivalent-age readings cannot be corrected after the event for the right activation energy. On a high-replacement mix, where true temperature sensitivity is furthest from the Type I default, that caveat carries most force.

What this means for maturity monitoring

Later-age specification changes where the risk sits

High-replacement mixes are increasingly specified at 56 days rather than 28, which BS 8500-1 permits. The Concrete Centre estimates the saving at roughly 15–20 kg/m³ of cement and 5–10 kg/m³ of embodied carbon for a Class S cement concrete. That is the point of using these binders.

It also moves the problem. Conformity moves to 56 days; striking, backpropping and load application do not move at all. A mix designed for 56 days sits at just under 90% of the equivalent 28-day mix's strength at 28 days, and correspondingly less in the first week — which is when the decisions that maturity monitoring informs are actually taken. The specified age is now nowhere near the decision, so early-age strength has to be demonstrated rather than inferred from the grade on the delivery ticket. See 28-day strength for the specification detail.

A nuance on the crossover effect

The crossover concern needs qualifying for these mixes rather than repeating uncritically. Early thermal rise does accelerate early strength at the cost of later strength. But at a given peak temperature, the reduction in long-term strength is smaller for concretes with high fly ash or GGBS replacement than for CEM I. Controlling early thermal rise still matters for Class S cements — CIRIA C766 covers why, for restrained-deformation cracking as much as strength — but the long-term strength penalty from a given peak is less severe than the CEM I case that most crossover warnings are drawn from.

Why this is particularly relevant to OTB

For lower-carbon mixes, the useful question is not simply “Does the sensor have a calibration curve?” It is “How was the maturity function selected, how were its parameters determined for this binder system, and how was the strength–maturity relationship established and verified?”

A supplier who cannot answer the middle part of that question is offering a curve, not a calibration.

Related pages

Nurse–Saul vs Arrhenius maturity functions Limitations of the maturity method Does concrete reach full strength at 28 days? How a strength–maturity relationship is established

References

Standards are cited by identifier and title. Consult the current licensed standard text before making project decisions. Publisher links were verified on 11 August 2026 and should be rechecked before publication.

Content and sources last reviewed 11 August 2026.